Looking Beyond the Bestop Supertop Truck 2 5.8? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
If you are researching bestop supertop truck 2 5 8 alternatives, you likely already know the original offers a no-drill install for 5.8 ft beds. The Bestop Supertop Truck 2 features a fully integrated bow system and attaches with four clamps. It is designed for one-person operation and includes a DOT-approved tinted rear window. This makes it a practical soft top for owners who value easy installation and lightweight coverage.
However, you might want different specs. Perhaps you need a hard cover for better security or a roll-up style for full bed access. The alternatives listed here were chosen because their specs overlap with the original. Each option fits the 5.8 ft Chevy Silverado or GMC Sierra bed. You can compare soft roll-ups against hard tri-folds to find the right balance of weight, material, and protection for your specific needs.
Our top pick: Bestop Supertop Truck 2 5.8 ft.
How these alternatives compare
WHALEMOTOR Soft Roll-Up 5.8 ft
The WHALEMMOTOR Soft Roll-Up replaces the Supertop’s rigid structure with a flexible vinyl design. You get a simpler, lower-profile cover that rolls up completely for full bed access. It uses a soft structure rather than the integrated bow system found on the Bestop. This means less height but easier manual operation. It fits the same 5.8 ft bed for Silverado and Sierra trucks. You trade the Supertop’s rigid panels for a budget-friendly option that prioritizes basic weather protection and easy storage over secure, upright coverage. It is a practical choice if you want minimal visual bulk.
Calffree Hard Tri-Fold 5.8ft
The Calffree Hard Tri-Fold offers a rigid aluminum construction instead of the Supertop’s soft fabric panels. This provides higher load capacity and better security for your cargo. The tri-fold design folds neatly at the front of the bed, unlike the Supertop which removes entirely. It maintains the no-drill clamp installation for easy setup. You gain a hard shell that resists impact and offers a more permanent look. However, you lose the ability to remove the cover completely in one piece. It is ideal for owners who need to carry heavy items on top of the cover or want maximum theft deterrence.
RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up for Silverado 1500 5.8 ft
The RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up is a lightweight, no-drill solution that contrasts with the Supertop’s heavier, multi-panel design. Weighing only 23 pounds, it is significantly lighter than the Bestop option. The roll-up mechanism allows you to access the entire bed quickly without removing panels. It uses a soft structure that sits low on the bed rails. This model is designed for 2019-2026 Silverado 1500s with 5.8 ft beds. You sacrifice the rigid weather sealing of the Supertop for a simpler, more affordable cover. It is best for those who prioritize quick access and low cost over the structured protection of a hard or semi-rigid top.
MOSTPLUS 5.8 ft Tri-Fold Soft Tonneau Cover
The MOSTPLUS Tri-Fold Soft Cover is designed specifically for fleetside beds, whereas the Supertop fits standard configurations. It uses a soft tri-fold structure that folds toward the cab, unlike the Supertop’s removable panels. This cover retains more bed space when folded compared to the Supertop’s full removal. It attaches without drilling, similar to the Bestop install. You get a lower profile and easier folding action. The trade-off is less complete weather protection compared to the Supertop’s integrated seals. It is a practical choice for fleetside owners who want a soft cover that folds neatly rather than removing completely.
ONINE Retractable Aluminum Tonneau Cover
The ONINE Retractable Aluminum Cover uses a hard aluminum shell that slides into a canister, unlike the Supertop’s removable panels. It weighs 122 pounds, making it much heavier and more permanent. The retractable design allows you to access any part of the bed without removing sections. It features a key lock for security, which the Supertop lacks. This option suits owners who want hard protection and rack versatility. You gain durability and a sleek, integrated look. You lose the ability to completely remove the cover. It is ideal for those who need daily access and high security without the hassle of handling multiple heavy panels.
Toptiny Hard Folding Aluminum Tonneau Cover
The Toptiny Hard Folding Cover uses a quad-fold aluminum design, offering four sections instead of the Supertop’s two main panels. It folds neatly at the front of the bed, preserving more bed space than the Supertop when open. The hard aluminum construction provides superior security and scratch resistance. It locks with your tailgate for added safety. The install is no-drill, matching the Bestop convenience. You trade the Supertop’s removable window panels for a fixed, hard-shell experience. It is best for owners who want a secure, rigid cover that stays on the truck and offers a premium, low-profile appearance without the bulk of full removal.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Bestop Supertop Truck 2 5.8 ft
Best for: easy install soft top
- Compatible Truck
- Chevy/GMC Silverado, Sierra 1500
- Bed Size
- 5.8 ft
- Installation
- No Drilling Required
- Operation
- One person operation
- Dimensions
- 66.2 × 27.5 × 5.5 inches
View on Amazon: Bestop Supertop Truck 2 5.8 ft Affiliate link
This soft top covers a 5.8 ft bed on Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra 1500 trucks. It uses a fully integrated bow system with no loose hardware. Installation requires no drilling and uses four clamps. You can operate it from the side of the truck with one person. The black fabric includes DOT-approved tinted windows that roll into storage pockets.
Pros
- No drilling required for installation
- Fully integrated bow system
- One-person side operation
- DOT-approved tinted rear window
Cons
- Limited to 5.8 ft bed size
- Soft fabric offers less security than hard covers
- Windows roll into pockets rather than removing completely
Good fit if
- You want a quick install without tools
- You drive a 5.8 ft bed Silverado or Sierra
- You need a lightweight soft top
Skip if
- You have a 6.5 ft or 5 ft bed
- You prefer a hard folding cover
- You need full window removal
Verdict: Bestop Supertop Truck 2 5.8 ft is a practical soft top for owners of 2019-2020 Silverado or Sierra 1500 trucks who value easy installation and lightweight coverage.
WHALEMOTOR Soft Roll-Up 5.8 ft
Best for: budget protection of 5.8 ft truck beds
- Bed Size
- 5.8 ft
- Cover Style
- Soft Roll-Up
- Installation
- Tool-free
- Waterproof
- Weather-resistant
- Compatible Truck
- Chevy Silverado, GMC Sierra
View on Amazon: WHALEMOTOR Soft Roll-Up 5.8 ft Affiliate link
This WHALEMOTOR soft roll-up tonneau cover is designed for the 5.8 ft bed of 2007-2026 Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra 1500 trucks. It features a tool-free clamping installation and a durable, weather-resistant black vinyl construction. The aerodynamic design aims to reduce wind drag, potentially improving fuel efficiency. It includes side rails, clamps, and a weather strip for a secure fit.
Pros
- Tool-free installation using a straightforward clamping system
- Soft roll-up mechanism allows quick bed access
- Weather-resistant black vinyl construction
- Aerodynamic design reduces wind drag
Cons
- Soft material offers less security than hard covers
- Only weather-resistant, not fully waterproof
- Rolls up to cover the bed rail
Good fit if
- You want a low-cost cover for a 5.8 ft bed
- You need tool-free installation for a Silverado or Sierra
- You prefer easy roll-up access over hard folding
Skip if
- You have a 6.6 ft or 6.9 ft bed
- You need maximum security for high-value cargo
- You want a hard folding or retractable cover
Verdict: WHALEMOTOR Soft Roll-Up 5.8ft is a practical, budget-friendly option for owners of 5.8 ft bed Silverado or Sierra trucks who prioritize easy installation and weather protection over rigid security.
Calffree Hard Tri-Fold 5.8ft
Best for: Heavy cargo security on 5.8ft beds
- Bed Size
- 5.8ft Bed (69.6")
- Cover Style
- Hard Tri-Fold
- Installation
- No Tools or Drilling Required
- Waterproof
- Water resistance
- Compatible Truck
- Chevy Silverado, GMC Sierra
- Width
- 6-Inch
View on Amazon: Calffree Hard Tri-Fold 5.8ft Affiliate link
The Calffree Hard Tri-Fold covers 5.8-foot beds on 2007-2026 Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra 1500 trucks. It uses FRP and aluminum panels with a honeycomb structure to support up to 400 pounds. The cover offers water resistance and requires no tools for installation. This hard shell design helps reduce wind drag for better fuel efficiency while keeping cargo secure.
Pros
- Hard tri-fold construction with FRP and aluminum panels
- Supports up to 400 lbs of static weight
- No tools or drilling required for installation
- Water resistant protection against rain and snow
Cons
- Only offers water resistance, not full waterproofing
- 6-inch width reduces total bed space when folded
- No mention of a tailgate seal or drain tubes
Good fit if
- You need a hard cover that supports heavy loads
- You want a secure cover without drilling holes
- You drive a 5.8-foot bed Silverado or Sierra
Skip if
- You require fully waterproof protection in heavy rain
- You need maximum bed space when the cover is folded
- You drive a 6.7-foot or 6.9-foot bed truck
Verdict: Calffree Hard Tri-Fold 5.8ft is a sturdy option for owners of 5.8-foot bed Silverado or Sierra trucks who need high load capacity. It provides solid security and easy installation, though you should expect only water resistance rather than complete waterproofing.
RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up for Silverado 1500 5.8 ft
Best for: 2019-2026 Silverado 1500 5.8ft beds
- Compatible Truck
- 2019-2026 Chevy Silverado/GMC Sierra
- Bed Size
- 5.8 ft
- Cover Style
- Soft Roll-Up
- Lock Type
- Latch-Locking System
- Installation
- No drilling or cutting required
- Waterproof
- Weather-Resistant
View on Amazon: RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up for Silverado 1500 5.8 ft Affiliate link
This RHOBRA soft roll-up cover fits the 5.8ft bed of 2019-2026 Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra 1500 models. It uses 26.5oz weather-resistant material and a latch-locking system with all-metal clamps. The design rolls up fully for tall cargo. It weighs 23 pounds and requires no drilling for installation. This option suits you if you need a budget-friendly, easy-to-use cover for a specific short bed.
Pros
- Rolls up fully for easy access
- 26.5oz weather-resistant material
- No drilling required for installation
- All-metal clamps for secure fit
Cons
- Soft material offers less impact protection
- Limited to 5.8ft bed size only
- No dedicated key lock mechanism
Good fit if
- You own a 2019-2026 Silverado with a 5.8ft bed
- You want a simple roll-up design
- You prefer no-drill installation
Skip if
- You have a 6.6ft bed
- You need hard cover security
- You drive a 2018 or older model
Verdict: RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up for 5.8ft Beds is a practical, no-drill solution for owners of 2019-2026 Silverado 1500s with the 5.8ft bed who prioritize easy access and budget pricing.
MOSTPLUS 5.8 ft Tri-Fold Soft Tonneau Cover
Best for: 2014-2018 fleetside 5.8 ft beds
- Compatible Truck
- Chevrolet Silverado / GMC Sierra 1500
- Bed Size
- 5.8 ft
- Cover Style
- Tri-Fold Soft
- Material
- Vinyl, Aluminum
- Installation
- No Drilling
- Waterproof
- Waterproof & UV resistant
View on Amazon: MOSTPLUS 5.8 ft Tri-Fold Soft Tonneau Cover Affiliate link
The MOSTPLUS tri-fold soft cover fits fleetside 5.8 ft beds on 2014-2018 Silverado and Sierra 1500 trucks. It uses double-sided tear-resistant vinyl over powder-coated aluminum frames. Four horizontal crossbars provide structural stability. The design requires no drilling for installation. It includes a stick touch lamp and offers water and UV resistance for your cargo.
Pros
- Double-sided tear-resistant vinyl construction
- Powder-coated aluminum frame with four crossbars
- No-drill clamp installation
- Waterproof and UV resistant material
- Includes stick touch lamp
Cons
- Limited to fleetside 5.8 ft bed only
- Does not fit 2019+ non-classic models
- Soft vinyl offers less security than hard covers
Good fit if
- You own a 2014-2018 Silverado or Sierra 1500
- You have a fleetside 5.8 ft bed
- You want a simple no-drill install
Skip if
- You drive a 2019+ Silverado or Sierra
- You have a stepside or bed longer than 5.8 ft
- You need hard-shell security
Verdict: MOSTPLUS Tri-Fold Soft Cover 5.8ft is a practical option for owners of 2014-2018 fleetside trucks who prioritize easy installation and weather protection over rigid security.
ONINE Retractable Aluminum Tonneau Cover
Best for: 5.8 ft beds needing rack versatility
- Compatible Truck
- 2019-2026 Chevy Silverado/GMC Sierra
- Bed Size
- 5.8ft Bed
- Cover Style
- Retractable Hard
- Material
- All-Aluminum
- Lock Type
- Integrated locking system
- Installation
- No-Drill Installation
View on Amazon: ONINE Retractable Aluminum Tonneau Cover Affiliate link
This ONINE retractable tonneau cover is built from aluminum slats with a matte black powder coating. It fits the 5.8 ft bed of 2019-2026 Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra 1500 trucks. The design includes an integrated T-slot rail for racks and an IP56 waterproof rating. You get a manual key lock and no-drill clamp-on installation. It weighs 122 pounds and offers a hard-shell retractable style.
Pros
- All-aluminum slat construction with matte black finish
- IP56 waterproof and dustproof rating
- Integrated T-slot rail system for accessories
- Manual key lock security
- No-drill clamp-on installation
Cons
- Heavy 122-pound build
- Manual operation requires physical effort
- Some models may need small holes for drain tubes
Good fit if
- You need a hard retractable cover for a 5.8 ft bed
- You want to mount rack accessories via T-slots
- You prefer no-drill installation
Skip if
- You have a CarbonPro bed
- You want a power-operated cover
- You have a 5.5 ft or 6.5 ft bed
Verdict: ONINE Manual Retractable Hard Cover provides a durable aluminum shell for 5.8 ft beds. It suits owners who need rack versatility and hard protection without drilling.
Toptiny Hard Folding Aluminum Tonneau Cover
Best for: 5.8ft bed owners needing secure hard folding
- Bed Size
- 5'8" Bed (69.6")
- Cover Style
- Hard Folding
- Material
- Aluminum
- Installation
- Clamps
- Waterproof
- Water-Resistant
- Compatible Truck
- Chevy Silverado, GMC Sierra
View on Amazon: Toptiny Hard Folding Aluminum Tonneau Cover Affiliate link
The Toptiny THTF029 is a hard folding tonneau cover for the 5.8-foot bed of 2007-2026 Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra 1500 trucks. It uses aluminum panels with a shine-finish to resist scratches and UV damage. The cover folds into four sections for storage. It includes clamps for installation and locks fully when the tailgate is closed. This option suits those needing a secure, weather-resistant cover for their specific truck bed size.
Pros
- Aluminum panels with shine-finish resist scratches and UV damage
- Folds into four sections for manageable storage
- Fully locks when the tailgate is closed for security
- Includes clamps for straightforward installation
Cons
- Only water resistant, not fully waterproof
- Does not fit the CarbonPro bed option
- No remote or electronic locking mechanism mentioned
Good fit if
- You drive a 2007-2026 Chevy Silverado or GMC Sierra 1500 with a 5.8-foot bed
- You need a hard cover that folds for full bed access
- You want a cover that locks securely with the tailgate
Skip if
- You have a CarbonPro bed that requires a specific fit
- You need a fully waterproof seal for heavy rain exposure
- You prefer a soft roll-up or retractable hard cover style
Verdict: Toptiny Hard Folding 5.8ft Bed Cover is a solid choice for owners of 5.8-foot bed trucks who prioritize security and scratch-resistant aluminum construction. It works best if you need a hard cover that folds neatly and locks with your tailgate.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Bestop Supertop Truck 2 5.8 ft | WHALEMOTOR Soft Roll-Up 5.8 ft | Calffree Hard Tri-Fold 5.8ft | RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up for Silverado 1500 5.8 ft | MOSTPLUS 5.8 ft Tri-Fold Soft Tonneau Cover | ONINE Retractable Aluminum Tonneau Cover | Toptiny Hard Folding Aluminum Tonneau Cover |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Compatible Truck | Chevy/GMC Silverado, Sierra 1500 | not stated | not stated | 2019-2026 Chevy Silverado/GMC Sierra | Chevrolet Silverado / GMC Sierra 1500 | 2019-2026 Chevy Silverado/GMC Sierra | not stated |
| Bed Size | 5.8 ft | 5.8 ft | 5.8ft Bed (69.6") | 5.8 ft | 5.8 ft | 5.8ft Bed | 5'8" Bed (69.6") |
| Cover Style | not stated | Soft Roll-Up | Hard Tri-Fold | Soft Roll-Up | Tri-Fold Soft | Retractable Hard | Hard Folding |
| Material | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Vinyl, Aluminum | All-Aluminum | Aluminum |
| Lock Type | not stated | not stated | not stated | Latch-Locking System | not stated | Integrated locking system | not stated |
| Installation | No Drilling Required | Tool-free | No Tools or Drilling Required | No drilling or cutting required | No Drilling | No-Drill Installation | Clamps |
| Waterproof | not stated | Weather-resistant | Water resistance | Weather-Resistant | Waterproof & UV resistant | IP56-rated waterproof | Water-Resistant |
| Operation | One person operation | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Structure | not stated | Soft | Hard | Soft | Soft | Hard | Hard |
| Bed Type | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Fleetside | not stated | not stated |
| Size | Chevy/GMC 2019-2020 Silverado/Sierra 1500; 2020 2500/3500; For 5.8 ft. bed | 5.8ft for 07-26 1500 | 5.8 FT Bed | 19-26 Silverado-5.8ft | 5.8FT | Silverado/Sierra 1500 | 5.8ft Bed | 5.8FT Bed |
| Width | 27.5 inches | not stated | 6-Inch | not stated | not stated | not stated | 6-Inch |
| Finish | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | Black | not stated |
| Dimensions | 66.2 × 27.5 × 5.5 inches | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Weight | not stated | not stated | not stated | 23 pounds | not stated | 122 pounds | not stated |
| Color | Black | Black | 2007-2027 1500 | Black | Tri Fold | Retractable | 2007-2027 1500 |
| Model | 7731835 | Soft Rolling | CFFBM-0029 | PR-TNC-CY-SD-19P-58 | M3220202Y-1 | O9-K44 | THTF029 |
Frequently asked questions
What is the best tonneau cover for a 5.8 ft Silverado bed?
The Bestop Supertop Truck 2 is the top pick for easy installation and lightweight coverage on 5.8 ft beds. It fits 2019-2020 Silverado and Sierra 1500 trucks. The cover measures 66.2 inches long and 27.5 inches wide. It uses a black vinyl top with an integrated bow system.
Which soft roll-up cover is best for budget protection?
The WHALEMMOTOR Soft Roll-Up is the best budget option for 5.8 ft beds. It is designed for 2007-2026 1500 models. The black vinyl design rolls up completely for full bed access. It offers practical weather protection without the rigid structure of hard covers.
What is the best hard tri-fold cover for heavy cargo?
The Calffree Hard Tri-Fold is the best premium choice for heavy cargo security. It fits 5.8 ft beds on 2007-2026 1500 trucks. The model CFFBM-0029 provides sturdy protection. You should expect water resistance rather than complete waterproofing. It installs easily for secure coverage.
Is there a no-drill soft cover for newer Silverado models?
The RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up is a practical no-drill solution for 2019-2026 Silverado 1500s. It weighs 23 pounds and fits 5.8 ft beds. The black cover prioritizes easy access and budget pricing. It attaches without requiring permanent modifications to your truck bed.
Which tonneau cover works best for fleetside beds?
The MOSTPLUS Tri-Fold Soft Cover is the best option for fleetside beds. It fits 5.8 ft beds on 2014-2018 trucks. The model M3220202Y-1 provides easy installation and weather protection. It is a soft structure that folds for convenient bed access.
What is the best retractable hard cover for rack versatility?
The ONINE Retractable Aluminum Tonneau Cover is the best retractable option. It weighs 122 pounds and provides a durable aluminum shell. It fits 5.8 ft beds and uses a key lock for security. It suits owners who need rack versatility without drilling.
Which hard folding cover offers the most secure storage?
The Toptiny Hard Folding Aluminum Cover is the best quad-fold choice for security. It fits 5.8 ft beds on 2007-2026 1500 trucks. The model THTF029 features scratch-resistant aluminum construction. It folds neatly and locks with your tailgate for solid protection.