Gator Soft Roll-Up Tonneau Cover Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You might be looking for gator soft roll up truck bed tonneau cover alternatives if you need different specs or a better fit for your Ram 1500. The original Gator cover offers a soft roll-up design with gear straps for cargo organization. It installs without drilling and provides a water-sealed surface for 5'7" or 6'4" beds. Some users may prefer a lighter cover, a different bed length, or a brand with a tighter seal.
This list includes 6 similar picks that share key specifications with the Gator model. We selected these alternatives because their specs overlap with the original product. All options are soft roll-up covers designed for Dodge Ram 1500 trucks. You will find variations in weight, width, and height. Some covers focus on budget-friendly durability, while others offer a flush matte black finish. Each pick addresses specific needs like cargo keepers or easy manual access. Review the specs to find the right match for your truck bed size and usage requirements.
Our top pick: Gator Soft Roll-Up Tonneau Cover with Gear Straps.
How these covers compare to Gator
OEDRO Soft Roll-Up 5.7 ft Ram 1500
The OEDRO Soft Roll-Up offers a slightly different profile with a width of 10.2 inches and a height of 5.31 inches. It weighs 24 pounds, which is just one pound lighter than the Gator cover. This model is designed for 5.6-foot beds, making it a close match for the 5.7-foot requirement. You get a basic manual roll-up system without the integrated gear straps found on the Gator. If you prioritize a lower profile and simpler mechanics over built-in cargo keepers, this is a practical alternative. It provides essential weather protection and easy access without the extra bulk of the Gator's storage features.
LEDKINGDOMUS Soft Roll-Up 5.7ft
The LEDKINGDOMUS Soft Roll-Up is built for 5.7-foot beds and shares similar dimensions with the OEDRO option, measuring 10.2 inches wide and 5.31 inches high. It lacks the gear straps included with the Gator cover, focusing instead on a budget-friendly soft design. The cover is water-resistant but not fully waterproof, which is a step down from the Gator's water-sealed surface. You trade the Gator's cargo organization for a lower price point. This pick suits Ram 1500 Classic owners who need durable protection without the added cost of specialized storage straps. It offers a straightforward roll-up experience for basic bed coverage.
RealTruck TruXedo Pro X15 Soft Roll Up
The TruXedo Pro X15 stands out with a significantly lighter weight of 9.5 pounds compared to the Gator's 25 pounds. It features a matte black finish for a flush, low-profile look. The cover is 9.5 inches wide and 5.25 inches high, sitting flatter than the Gator's 10-inch height. It is designed for 5.7-foot beds and installs without drilling. You give up the gear straps for a sleeker aesthetic and easier handling. This option is ideal for drivers who want a minimal visual footprint and easy installation. The lightweight design makes it simpler to roll up and secure, offering a different priority than the Gator's cargo-focused approach.
RealTruck TruXedo TruXport Soft Roll-Up 6' 4" Bed
The TruXedo TruXport is designed for 6.4-foot beds, making it a direct alternative for owners with larger beds compared to the Gator's 5.7-foot or 6.4-foot options. It weighs 25.8 pounds, similar to the Gator's 25 pounds. This cover emphasizes a tight seal and durable vinyl construction. It lacks the gear straps found on the Gator but offers consistent tension control for reliable manual access. You choose this if you need a secure fit for a longer bed without the complexity of hard panels. It provides solid weather protection and easy access, prioritizing a tight seal over the cargo organization features of the Gator cover.
RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up 6.4ft Bed Cover
The RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up is specifically sized for 6.4-foot beds on 2009-2018 Ram 1500 models. It is a black soft cover that provides weather-resistant protection. Unlike the Gator, which includes gear straps for cargo management, this model focuses on basic bed coverage. It offers a practical solution for owners who need a tight seal and easy access without the added features of the Gator. You trade the Gator's modern 2019-2026 fit for a cover designed for earlier Ram models. This pick is suitable for those with older trucks who want a simple, durable roll-up cover without the extra cost of integrated storage straps.
Tyger Auto T1 Soft Roll-Up 5.7 ft
The Tyger Auto T1 features aluminum rails and a robust vinyl build, emphasizing durability. It measures 67.4 inches wide and 1.3 inches high, offering a very low profile compared to the Gator's 10-inch height. The cover is designed for 5.7-foot beds. You sacrifice the gear straps and the Gator's water-sealed surface for a focus on material strength and adjustable tension. This option suits users who prioritize the longevity of the rails and cover material over cargo organization. The low height provides a sleek look, while the aluminum rails offer structural support. It is a durable choice for those who want a simple, tough soft roll-up cover.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Gator Soft Roll-Up Tonneau Cover with Gear Straps
Best for: Ram 1500 owners needing cargo keepers
- Compatible Truck
- Dodge Ram 1500
- Bed Size
- 5' 7" Bed
- Cover Style
- Soft Roll-Up
- Installation
- No drilling required
- Size
- 5.5ft Bed
- Dimensions
- 82 × 6 × 10 inches
View on Amazon: Gator Soft Roll-Up Tonneau Cover with Gear Straps Affiliate link
This Gator soft roll-up tonneau cover fits 2019-2026 Dodge Ram 1500 trucks with 5'7" beds. It uses a clamp-on system for no-drill installation in under 30 minutes. The cover features a single cable pull lock and water-sealed fabric to block rain and snow. Adjustable Gear Hold keepers organize cargo inside the bed. It weighs 25 pounds and sits 6 inches wide.
Pros
- No-drill clamp-on installation takes less than 30 minutes
- Water-sealed fabric blocks rain, snow, dirt, and dust
- Includes adjustable Gear Hold cargo keepers to prevent sliding
- Single cable pull lock secures the cover
Cons
- Soft vinyl material offers less impact resistance than hard covers
- Water-sealed design is not fully waterproof against heavy leaks
- Limited to 5'7" bed size for this specific model
Good fit if
- You need a quick no-drill install on a 2019-2026 Ram 1500
- You want adjustable cargo keepers to secure loose items
- You prefer a low-profile soft roll-up design
Skip if
- You require a hard folding or retractable cover
- You have a 6'4" bed and need the larger variant
- You need fully waterproof protection against driving rain
Verdict: Gator Soft Roll-Up w/ Gear Straps provides a secure, weather-resistant fit for 5'7" Ram 1500 beds with convenient cargo management. It suits owners who value easy installation and organized storage over maximum hard-shell durability.
OEDRO Soft Roll-Up 5.7 ft Ram 1500
Best for: Ram 1500 owners needing basic manual protection
- Compatible Truck
- 2009-2024 Ram 1500 Classic
- Bed Size
- 5.7 ft Bed
- Cover Style
- Soft Roll Up
- Material
- Double layer PVC, Aluminum
- Lock Type
- Tailgate latch lock system
- Installation
- No drilling
View on Amazon: OEDRO Soft Roll-Up 5.7 ft Ram 1500 Affiliate link
The OEDRO soft roll-up tonneau cover fits 5.7ft beds on 2009-2024 Ram 1500 models. It uses double-layer PVC for UV and weather resistance. The cover rolls up manually and stays tight with hook-and-loop side seals. You get a tailgate latch lock for security. Installation requires no drilling, though you may need to cut small holes for over-the-bedrail bedliners. It weighs 24 pounds.
Pros
- Double-layer PVC construction resists UV and weather
- Tailgate latch lock system secures cargo
- No drilling required for standard bedliners
- Hook-and-loop side seals keep out dust and rain
Cons
- Manual operation lacks remote or electric convenience
- May require small cuts for over-the-bedrail bedliners
- Single lock point at the tailgate only
Good fit if
- You drive a 2009-2024 Ram 1500 with a 5.7ft bed
- You want a manual cover that rolls up easily
- You prefer no-drill installation on under-the-bedrail bedliners
Skip if
- You need a hard cover for maximum security
- You have a 6.4ft or 8ft bed
- You want electric or remote-controlled operation
Verdict: OEDRO Soft Roll-Up for Ram 1500 5.7ft is a solid, manual option for Ram owners who want basic weather protection and easy access without complex installation.
LEDKINGDOMUS Soft Roll-Up 5.7ft
Best for: Ram 1500 Classic 5.7 ft beds
- Compatible Truck
- 2009-2024 Dodge Ram 1500 Classic
- Bed Size
- 5.7 ft
- Cover Style
- Soft Roll-Up
- Material
- PVC
- Lock Type
- Tail-end lock
- Waterproof
- Water-Resistant
View on Amazon: LEDKINGDOMUS Soft Roll-Up 5.7ft Affiliate link
This LEDKINGDOMUS cover is a soft roll-up design built for the 2009-2024 Ram 1500 Classic with a 5.7 ft bed. It uses double-layer PVC material for durability and features a tail-end locking mechanism with a drawstring for secure closure. The cover measures 10.2 inches in width when rolled. It offers water-resistant protection and aims to improve fuel efficiency by reducing wind drag. You get a straightforward, budget-friendly option for your truck bed.
Pros
- Double-layer PVC construction for wear resistance
- Tail-end locking mechanism with drawstring design
- Water-resistant protection for the truck bed
- Streamlined shape aids fuel efficiency
Cons
- Only water-resistant, not fully waterproof
- 10.2-inch roll-up width takes up bed space
- Limited to 5.7 ft bed size only
Good fit if
- You own a 2009-2024 Ram 1500 Classic
- You need a cover for a 5.7 ft bed
- You want a soft roll-up style
Skip if
- You require a fully waterproof seal
- You have a 6.4 ft bed
- You prefer a hard tri-fold cover
Verdict: LEDKINGDOMUS Soft Roll-Up 5.7ft fits Ram 1500 Classic owners needing a durable, water-resistant cover for a 5.7 ft bed. It sacrifices full waterproofing and minimal roll-up bulk for a practical, budget-friendly soft design.
RealTruck TruXedo Pro X15 Soft Roll Up
Best for: Ram 1500 owners wanting a flush matte black fit
- Compatible Truck
- 2019-2027 Dodge Ram 1500
- Bed Size
- 5' 7" Bed (67.4")
- Cover Style
- Soft Roll Up
- Material
- RTxTechWeave, aluminum
- Size
- 5.5ft Bed
- Dimensions
- 80.5 × 9.5 × 5.25 inches
View on Amazon: RealTruck TruXedo Pro X15 Soft Roll Up Affiliate link
This soft roll-up tonneau cover fits 2019-2024 Dodge Ram 1500 trucks with a 5' 7" bed. It features a matte black woven fabric that sits flush with the bed rails. The cover rolls up securely using a trigger latch on the driver side. Installation requires no drilling and takes under 30 minutes. It is designed for users who want a low-profile look and quick access to their truck bed.
Pros
- Matte black woven fabric reduces visible dust and dirt
- Sits flush with truck bed rails for a low profile
- One-finger trigger latch allows quick opening and rolling
- No-drill clamp installation completes in under 30 minutes
- Constructed with materials made in the USA
Cons
- Only secures with a basic trigger latch mechanism
- Does not fit trucks with a split tailgate
- Limited to the 5' 7" bed size for this model
Good fit if
- You own a 2019-2024 Dodge Ram 1500 with a 5' 7" bed
- You prefer a matte black finish that blends with the truck
- You want a cover that installs without drilling into the bed
Skip if
- You have a Ram with a multi-function split tailgate
- You need a hard cover for maximum security
- You require a 6' 4" bed size option
Verdict: TruXedo Pro X15 5'7" Matte Black offers a sleek, low-profile design for 2019-2024 Dodge Ram 1500 owners. It suits drivers who value easy, no-drill installation and a flush fit that does not interfere with bed lines.
RealTruck TruXedo TruXport Soft Roll-Up 6' 4" Bed
Best for: Ram 1500 owners needing a tight seal
- Compatible Truck
- Dodge Ram 1500, 2500/3500
- Bed Size
- 6' 4"
- Cover Style
- Soft Roll-Up
- Material
- Vinyl
- Lock Type
- Automatic slam latch system
- Installation
- No Drilling
View on Amazon: RealTruck TruXedo TruXport Soft Roll-Up 6' 4" Bed Affiliate link
The TruXedo TruXport is a soft roll-up tonneau cover designed for 2009-2018 Ram 1500 trucks with a 6'4" bed. It uses durable RTxVinyl material and features an automatic slam-latch locking system. The cover includes a spring-loaded SureTension Control System to prevent edge curling. It weighs 25.8 pounds and installs without drilling. This manual operation cover opens from either side of the tailgate for convenient access.
Pros
- RTxVinyl material resists tearing and fading
- Automatic slam-latch secures the cover
- SureTension Control prevents edge curling
- Opens from either side of the tailgate
- No drilling required for installation
Cons
- Manual operation lacks motorized convenience
- Limited to specific Ram 1500 model years
- Heavier at 25.8 pounds than some competitors
Good fit if
- You own a 2009-2018 Ram 1500 with a 6'4" bed
- You want a tight fit without manual adjustments
- You prefer a durable vinyl cover that opens from either side
Skip if
- You need a cover for a Ram 2500/3500
- You want a motorized roll-up system
- You have a bed length other than 6'4"
Verdict: TruXedo TruXport 6'4" Soft Roll-Up offers a secure, no-drill solution for Ram 1500 owners who value a tight seal and durable vinyl construction. It is ideal for those who need reliable manual access and consistent tension control.
RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up 6.4ft Bed Cover
Best for: Dodge Ram 1500 owners with 6.4ft beds
- Compatible Truck
- 2009-2026 Dodge Ram 1500, 2500, 3500
- Bed Size
- 6.4 ft
- Cover Style
- Soft Roll-Up
- Material
- Stainless Steel
- Lock Type
- Latch-Locking System
- Installation
- No-Drill
View on Amazon: RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up 6.4ft Bed Cover Affiliate link
This RHOBRA cover is designed exclusively for the 6.4-foot bed of Dodge Ram trucks. It uses a soft roll-up style with 26.5oz waterproof material to protect cargo. The latch-locking system secures the cover, while stainless steel crossbars provide tension. You get a streamlined look that reduces wind noise. It installs without drilling, making it a straightforward option for owners of this specific bed size.
Pros
- Specific fit for 6.4ft bed without Rambox
- 26.5oz waterproof material blocks rain and snow
- Latch-locking system with all-metal clamps
- Stainless steel crossbars prevent water pooling
- No drilling required for installation
Cons
- Only fits 6.4ft bed, not other sizes
- Manual latch system lacks remote or key lock
- Soft material offers less security than hard covers
Good fit if
- You own a Dodge Ram with a 6.4ft bed
- You need a weatherproof cover for daily use
- You want easy access to the entire bed
Skip if
- You have a 5.7ft or 6.4ft bed with Rambox
- You need a hard folding or retractable cover
- You require a remote-controlled locking mechanism
Verdict: RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up for 6.4ft Ram Bed is a practical, weather-resistant option for Dodge Ram owners with the 6.4-foot bed. It provides solid protection and easy access without the complexity of hard covers.
Tyger Auto T1 Soft Roll-Up 5.7 ft
Best for: durability-focused soft roll-up users
- Bed Size
- 5'7" (67")
- Cover Style
- Soft Roll-Up
- Material
- 24oz marine-grade vinyl, aluminum rails
- Lock Type
- Latch lock system at tailgate
- Installation
- No Drilling
- Compatible Truck
- Dodge Ram 1500, Ram
View on Amazon: Tyger Auto T1 Soft Roll-Up 5.7 ft Affiliate link
This Tyger Auto T1 cover is a soft roll-up design for the 5.7-foot bed. It uses 24oz marine-grade vinyl with built-in crossbars for support. Aluminum side rails and stainless steel clamps secure the unit. You adjust tension to keep the vinyl tight. It seals with side Velcro and uses a tailgate latch. This option suits you if you need a durable, US-patented cover without drilling.
Pros
- 24oz marine-grade vinyl construction
- Aluminum side rails and stainless clamps
- Adjustable tension system
- No drilling required
Cons
- Velcro side seals may trap debris
- Latch lock only at tailgate
- Requires bedliner modification for over-the-rail liners
Good fit if
- You want a soft roll-up cover
- You prefer aluminum rails over plastic
- You have a 5.7-foot bed
Skip if
- You need hard folding panels
- You have a RamBox bed
- You want remote locking
Verdict: Tyger Auto T1 5.7ft Soft Roll-Up offers a robust vinyl build with aluminum rails. It fits you if you prioritize material durability and adjustable tension over hard panel convenience.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Gator Soft Roll-Up Tonneau Cover with Gear Straps | OEDRO Soft Roll-Up 5.7 ft Ram 1500 | LEDKINGDOMUS Soft Roll-Up 5.7ft | RealTruck TruXedo Pro X15 Soft Roll Up | RealTruck TruXedo TruXport Soft Roll-Up 6' 4" Bed | RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up 6.4ft Bed Cover | Tyger Auto T1 Soft Roll-Up 5.7 ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Compatible Truck | Dodge Ram 1500 | 2009-2024 Ram 1500 Classic | 2009-2024 Dodge Ram 1500 Classic | 2019-2027 Dodge Ram 1500 | Dodge Ram 1500, 2500/3500 | 2009-2026 Dodge Ram 1500, 2500, 3500 | not stated |
| Bed Size | 5' 7" Bed | 5.7 ft Bed | 5.7 ft | 5' 7" Bed (67.4") | 6' 4" | 6.4 ft | 5'7" (67") |
| Cover Style | Soft Roll-Up | Soft Roll Up | Soft Roll-Up | Soft Roll Up | Soft Roll-Up | Soft Roll-Up | Soft Roll-Up |
| Material | not stated | Double layer PVC, Aluminum | PVC | RTxTechWeave, aluminum | Vinyl | Stainless Steel | 24oz marine-grade vinyl, aluminum rails |
| Lock Type | not stated | Tailgate latch lock system | Tail-end lock | not stated | Automatic slam latch system | Latch-Locking System | Latch lock system at tailgate |
| Installation | No drilling required | No drilling | not stated | not stated | No Drilling | No-Drill | No Drilling |
| Waterproof | not stated | not stated | Water-Resistant | not stated | not stated | Waterproof | not stated |
| Structure | Soft | Soft | Soft | Soft | Soft | Soft | Soft |
| Size | 5.5ft Bed | 5.6ft Bed | 5.7ft Bed | 5.5ft Bed | 6' 4" Bed | 09-18 Ram 1500-6.4ft | 5.7ft Bed |
| Width | 6 inches | 10.2 inches | 10.2 inches | 9.5 inches | 3-Inch | not stated | 67.4 inches |
| Dimensions | 82 × 6 × 10 inches | 70.8 × 10.2 × 5.31 inches | 70.9 × 10.2 × 5.31 inches | 80.5 × 9.5 × 5.25 inches | not stated | not stated | 69.1 × 67.4 × 1.3 inches |
| Weight | 25 pounds | 24 pounds | not stated | 9.5 pounds | 25.8 pounds | not stated | not stated |
| Model | 138693 | MAOA-0020 | MAMUSuKX7c | 1485901 | 246901 | PR-TNC-DG-RM-0918-63 | TG-BC1D9018 |
| Color | not stated | BLACK | black | Black | Black | Black | T1 Soft Roll-Up |
If you need portable storage instead of a cover, review marksign truck bed cargo bag alternatives for your truck.
Frequently asked questions
Which soft roll-up tonneau cover is best for a 5'7" Ram 1500 bed?
The Gator Soft Roll-Up Tonneau Cover with Gear Straps is the top pick for this bed size. It includes integrated gear straps to help secure cargo while driving. The cover weighs 25 pounds and rolls up to a width of 6 inches. This compact roll allows for easy access to the bed while keeping the cover secure.
What is the lightest soft roll-up cover for a Ram 1500?
The RealTruck TruXedo Pro X15 Soft Roll Up is the lightest option listed. It weighs only 9.5 pounds, making it significantly lighter than the Gator cover at 25 pounds. This low-profile cover features a matte black finish and rolls up to a width of 9.5 inches. Its lightweight design reduces stress on the bed rails during installation and use.
Are there soft roll-up covers available for a 6.4 ft Ram 1500 bed?
Yes, the RHOBRA Soft Roll-Up 6.4ft Bed Cover is designed specifically for this bed size. It fits 2009-2018 Dodge Ram 1500 models with the longer bed. This cover provides a weather-resistant seal without requiring drilling. It offers a practical alternative for owners who need coverage for the extended bed length rather than the standard 5.7 ft size.
Which tonneau cover offers the tightest seal for weather protection?
The RealTruck TruXedo TruXport Soft Roll-Up 6'4" Bed is noted for its tight seal. It uses durable vinyl construction to keep water out of the bed. The cover relies on consistent tension control to maintain this seal across the entire surface. This model is ideal for owners who prioritize weather resistance and secure cargo protection over a flush aesthetic.
How wide does the Gator soft roll-up cover get when fully rolled?
When fully rolled up, the Gator Soft Roll-Up Tonneau Cover occupies a width of 6 inches. This is narrower than the OEDRO cover, which rolls to 10.2 inches. The compact roll design ensures that the cover does not obstruct the rear window or limit visibility. It allows you to access most of the bed while keeping the cover stowed safely.
Does the Tyger Auto T1 cover use aluminum rails?
Yes, the Tyger Auto T1 Soft Roll-Up 5.7 ft features aluminum rails for support. These rails provide a robust structure for the vinyl cover material. The cover itself is designed for durability and includes adjustable tension controls. This combination of strong rails and flexible vinyl makes it a suitable choice for users who prioritize long-term material strength.
What is the weight difference between the Gator and OEDRO covers?
The Gator cover weighs 25 pounds, while the OEDRO Soft Roll-Up weighs 24 pounds. This is a one-pound difference, making them very similar in heft. Both covers are soft roll-up designs that install without drilling. The slight weight difference is unlikely to impact installation difficulty, as both are manageable for a single person to handle.